How Owner-Builders Should Compare Contractor and Trade Bids
Two proposals with different exclusions, allowances and assumptions are not directly comparable. Before selecting a contractor or trade, normalize what each number actually includes.
Write down the scope you expect
Use plans, specifications and a simple scope checklist so every bidder is pricing the same intended work.
Compare exclusions first
Missing work often explains a low bid. Identify permits, equipment, delivery, cleanup, patching, tax and coordination responsibilities where relevant.
Review allowances and alternates
An allowance is not a fixed product cost. Compare the amount, what it covers and what happens when the final selection differs.
Consider schedule and capacity
Price matters, but so do lead time, crew availability, sequencing and the contractor's ability to perform when the project needs the work.
Project review checklist
• Did bidders receive substantially the same scope information? • Are exclusions shown side by side? • Are allowances comparable? • Have schedule and availability been discussed before award?